Good little podcast there.
I totally agree with him that the "funnest" conditions to paddle in are not necessarily the "largest". Fun-ness plateaus when the sea is overly messy and a good downwind paddle turns into 'stay upright' practice. The funnest runs I've had were on 'big' days, but not the 'biggest' I've ever paddled in. Just saying, you not missing out on the greatest runs on the crazy days lots of times.
Considering how few rescues of surfski paddlers really occur compared to the number of runs done in large-to-crazy conditions I think is a testament that most of us have pretty decent judgement.
He made a very good point that I take to heart - when things go wrong, they typically went wrong before you ever touched the water. I always check my boat leash, paddle leash, bung, both straps on the life jacket, phone, flashlight, etc before leaving the beach. I usually find one thing I missed in the first go. (usually one strap on the PFD or the Bung being secure)
My personal line for calling off a paddle is "In these conditions, can I get back in the boat after swimming". Like they tell you at the Gorge, if the answer is maybe or no, you have no business being out there.
I hope to never call for rescue, and if I have to, I hope its because my boat broke up underneath me or a shark put a hole in it, not a lack of judgement. (If the boat breaks up underneath me, maybe that counts as lack of judgement though... no, ill call it equipment failure
) That would be horribly embarrassing at best, and a terrible guilt if anything negative happened to others as a result. Something for us all to keep in mind