Sam_Atlas wrote: Since I am larger (105 kg, 190 cm) I am guessing that these skis would be better choices than, say, a ski that has a length of 5.80.
I also suspect that these skis' performance is similar. However, what I would like to know are the small things about the skis: finish, fittings, durability, comfort and making adjustments. Also, are there any details that you love about the ski?
I know a guy that would be at least as heavy as you, possibly heavier and he paddles the EVO 2 and still swims quite a bit. But I think the EVO2 suits a bigger guy better than a Swordfish perhaps.
For me at 72kg the Swordfish does not feel like a large volume ski (like my Stellar SEL does) and the only complaint I have is the hump is too far forward for me and I've had to make a seat to push me forward a couple of inches although at your height this would not be an issue.
Finish? The seam looks a little rough and the scupper covers are a bit agricultural and can do some with some fairing to the hull, not a hard job to do. The bung to let water out falls out and everyone tapes over the hole instead of using the bung, I just use a sticker, looks good and not an issue.
Fittings? Yesterday I trimmed a little off the foot strap, there was a tail that was a bit long and it has damaged the tendon on the top of my right foot causing a painful cyst when I pull back on the strap, I've had to change my technique slightly and not pull on that side until it heals. I've also put a couple of my Stellar velcroed foot strap covers on for added comfit. I've moved the grab strap that was mounted on the port side of the cockpit to the middle of the top deck as I used to occasionally strike it with my paddle. Both easy modifications to make. When I first started paddling the Swordfish I noticed that there used to be a large gap under the footplate where my heel used to push into and get a bit painful after a while, I was going to fill it with something, now I don't notice it at all for some reason.
Durability? I have the Carbon Vacuum and durability has been excellant, no leaks or any damage suffered to date. Footplate is sturdy, steel cables for rudder faultless.
Comfort? Every ski I have ever had I've had to make my own seat for comfort and a better paddling position. The Swordfish was not different. Epic were the worse for me and I had to sell my V10L as I just couldn't get that right, my SES is the closest for comfort, my Swordfish took a long time to get the comfort right but I got there in the end. Many don't like the Swordfish for comfort where as Think seem to have a lot of happy customers in the comfort area.
Adjustments? Adjusting the footplate is easy with an allen key that stays with the ski, however its not micro adjustable like my Stellars are and I ended up making the micro adjustment with my seat position.
I also replaced the Fenn Sharkfin rudder with an Orka Surf rudder, I much prefer this rudder.
What I love about the ski is its a bit smaller than most of the elite skis, its very stable and catches small runs easily, I don't feel its particularly fast but a lot of that is probably just me. Its not the perfect ski for me, thats yet to be made. I also think its fantastic value for money here in NZ compared to the other brands that are available. However the new models coming in at the end of the month I notice that there has been a price jump.
For your size I think the EVO2 might be the better option but I have not paddled one so you can only try for yourself of get some other opinions.