Ya, its a beautiful rudder. The reality is that I'm not sure why it didn't work out. It just was more vague and stalled. It did also make the ski feel a little more stable though.
The ski is 6.6m with little rocker, so my gut feeling is that the large foil along with the thinner width didn't exert enough force before it would stall. Its sort of like turning a long thin wing abruptly vs a short wide wing. The thin one will stall and slide through the air while the shorter wider wing will pivot.
My guess is that if you have a ski with more recent rocker, the increased predictability and reduced force required by this rudder by way of its foil and height vs. width has to be amazing.
Again, my guess is that this boat needs a rudder to be very wide and with little foil to really "bite" the water and exert a lot of force solely by virtue of the angle of attack and not by flowing around the rudder, somewhat similar to the difference in a supersonic airplane wing vs. a regular wing. (I'm not a Naval engineer, so I realize this description probably only makes sense to me lol.)